Bodies from the Library 3 is the third (shocking!) collection of lost or obscure mystery stories brought to you by Tony Medawar. Not much intro needed.
We open with my first Lynn Brock: “Some Little Things.” Detective Colonel Gore is met in his office by an outraged member of Scotland Yard. Seems that the Chief Inspector has gone missing, and Gore’s office was the last place he was seen. It was over a stolen necklace belonging to a woman who’s found herself the object of scandal after getting in a car crash with an Important Personage. Well, Gore decides to take the case, and find some “little things” that point him in the direction of the truth. Not that the reader has any chance of solving this quite absurd little mystery. It’s fun, with good humor, though I thought that the masterminds of this whole thing got off quite lightly considering they subjected a man to water torture for being a bit of a jerk.
“Hot Steel” is a piece of wartime propaganda from Anthony Berkeley, where some in-jokes and careless comments allow Roger Sheringham to deduce what’s actually going on at a factory. It’s a warning about loose talk, which I guess was a major problem in Britain at the time.
Next up we have a broadcast script from Cyril Hare: “The Murder at Warbeck Hall.” It’s Christmas at Warbeck, and the family is gathering for some good times. Well, not really. Lord Warbeck is dying, though he’s at peace with it. Cousin Julius is planning an increase in the income tax that will spell the end of Warbeck Hall. And son Robert is a fascist who slaps his cousin around, and seduces the butler’s daughter. Needless to say, when the Christmas bells ring, he dies from poison in his drink. Officer Rogers, here to project Julius, solves the crime. The story’s charming enough, and Hare would later expand it into his famous An English Murder, but it’s not a good mystery. Rogers solves the crime by talking to the servants off-screen.
Next we have one of the major points of interest for mystery fans: An unpublished Sayers story, “The House of the Poplars.” Adrian Belford is that common mystery villain, the fool who embezzles to speculate on the stocks only to have it crash down around him. He needs money, but his wife is grasping, and frankly he’s tired of being errand boy for the sick woman. Thankfully for him, not so much for his wife, he makes the acquaintance of a certain man at a restaurant, who gives him a business card for Smith & Smith, Removals. Adrian is brought to the titular house where he meets Misters Smith, Smyth, Smythe, and Schmidt, who agree to help him with his “problem.” Apparently, these four appeared in one other story collected in In the Teeth of the Evidence, but I haven’t read it. I think that was good, since it meant I had no idea where this was going. Sayers aims for a dreamy, ethereal vibe that covers the end in a nice film of ambiguity.
Christopher Bush is next with “The Hampstead Murder.” The story opens by musing on the influence of coincidence, and uses the titular murder as an example. The narrator informs us that “A man in Scotland wrote a letter to The Times and, by chance, The Times found it interesting enough to print. Because of that letter, which had nothing whatever to do with murder, a woman was strangled in a London suburb.” The domino effect begins when writer Lutley Prentisse reads a letter from an annoyed policeman about the incompetence of his profession in detective stories, and authors’ ignorance of the inner workings of the police. Prentisse, who’s working on a mystery novel himself, is concerned enough about this to pay a visit to an actual private investigator’s office. The trouble begins when they ask him what he’s doing there, and the embarrassed Prentisse makes up an excuse…but I’ll leave this for the reader to find out. Good story overall.
Now the next story made me sit up and take notice: Not only is it by an American, but that American is Joseph Commings. Yes, we have another Senator Banner story! “The Scarecrow Murders” sees Senator Banner stopping by Cow Crossing to ask about a local murder. Someone blew Beverly Jelke’s head off with a shotgun while she was swimming. That means that the farm is now the property of her grasping brother Hudson. Then someone blows his head off while he stands on his front porch. In the morning, footprints are found, leading out to a scarecrow in the middle of a field. Only one set. Banner takes the liberty of locking up all the suspects and blocking their rooms with chairs, but hears clomping footprints in the hallway in the night (“It was a clumping sound, as if the shoes were hanging loose on feet that were mere bones—or sticks!”) before another shotgun blast rings out from a locked room…
This was great. I forgot how good Commings was. He had a real knack for interesting problems and good solutions. Unlike some of the other Banner stories, this isn’t just a reworked magic trick. It’s not a 100% original solution, but it’s genuinely clever. For locked room fans, this is worth getting the collection.
Agatha Christie follows up with “The Adventure of the Dog’s Ball.” Poirot is surprised when he gets a letter from one Matilda Wheeler, which obliquely refers to “the incident of the dog’s ball” and asks for Poirot’s assistance. The problem? The letter was written five months ago! Poirot sets out only to find that Miss Wheeler has already passed, from natural causes, of course…Christie fans will likely recognize this as the set-up to her novel Dumb Witness. That book holds the dishonor of being my least favorite Christie; I found it over-long and with some clunky cluing. This story is a improvement due to being 250 pages shorter. Still, there are problems: The initial hook, the delayed letter, ends up being an anticlimax. While the solution is a little better clued than some of Christie’s other shorts, even Poirot admits that the thing that gives the killer away has other explanations, and he ultimately bluffs them. But it’s a rare Christie (originally published in John Curran’s second study of her notebooks, Murder in the Making), and hard to dislike on those grounds.
Christopher St. John Sprigg follows up with “The Case of the Unlucky Airman.” The titular airman is Garnett, who’s aiming for a record. Mechanical issues stop him from making it, but he seems in cheerful enough spirits…so why did he shoot himself in the head in the hanger? Newspaperman Charles Venables is on the scene and quickly starts questioning the suicide theory. There’s a clever method of smuggling here, but the actual mystery is pretty simple, with a criminal gang at the heart of it.
Next up is “The Riddle of the Black Spade” by Stuart Palmer. “STATEMAN DIES IN FREAK ACCIDENT” the headlines scream, and rightly so. How many people die from an unfortunate golf ball to the head? It’s a bit much for the police, who set their eyes on the dead man’s foster son, a skilled golfer who could clobber dear old dad with a well-placed shot. Miss Withers is in attendance though and doubts the easy story. I just finished reading a string of Palmers, and on some level, this isn’t much better than them. The titular spade, a marking on the death ball that no one can find, doesn’t amount to much of anything. And yet, the ending is so over-the-top that I can’t help but enjoy it, in spite of its faults.
Josephine Bell follows with “A Torch at the Window.” A prowler flashes his torch (flashlight) through the windows of a hospital ward, frightening some of the residents and nurses. He goes uncaptured, but other than some stricter security measures, nothing comes of it. Then, a few nights later, one of the head nurses is killed by an intruder. This is a straightforward police procedural, not a bad example of the form, but not something to get overly excited about unless you’re a fan of Bell.
The next two entries are likely the other two hooks for interested mystery fans. First up is “Grand Guignol” by John Dickson Carr. The great sportsman De Saligny has a problem: His new wife Louise was formally married to Alexandre Laurent, before his mad bloodlust caused him to try to kill her. The marriage, sad to say, didn’t last. Now Laurent has escaped the asylum and is lurking around Paris, doubtless planning on revenging himself on Louise and her new beau. Complicating matters is that Laurent stopped by one of those magic plastic surgeons who can totally change one’s appearance, so he could be anybody. Henri Bencolin and other members of the French police are watching the happy couple, but they are helpless. De Saligny enters a nightclub card room, and when a waiter enters, he finds that the man has been decapitated. The windows are locked and the police were watching every exit, so how did the killer escape?
If this sounds familiar to you, that’s because Carr would rewrite this into his first novel, It Walks by Night. The book is better. This novella is good as it stands—Carr is in full exuberant Gothic mode—but there are some missteps. Bencolin determines a man’s height by shooting at him. The shocking endgame twist that forces the reader to rethink the entire book is delivered halfway through. The denouement is so over-the-top that ends up lacking impact compared to the book. Interestingly, Bencolin is less omniscient here, he missteps, a witness gets under his skin, his machinations get a man killed (not that he’s really bothered by that). But you can’t complain too much about having more Carr to read, and this is certainly worth your time.
Next is something even more fascinating: the script for an unaired pilot episode of Ngaio Marsh’s Inspector Alleyn series! “A Knotty Problem/The Slipknot” revolves around the opening of a new art gallery. Of course, there’s drama afoot. The gallery is showcasing the work of Dennis Rayburn, who’s facing accusations from his artist buddies that he’s a sell-out. Not to mention that the gallery’s main backer, Harold Tillet, is suspicious of all this fancy new art garbage. And another backer, Ruby Kerr-Bates, is all but having an affair with Dennis. So no surprise that something goes wrong at the opening: Someone switches out Dennis’s portrait of Tillet with an insulting cartoon. And at the same time, someone slips poison into Kerr-Bates’s drink. Luckily, Inspector Alleyn is taking a busman’s holiday.
This is merely okay. Marsh hasn’t really impressed me in the past, and this didn’t win me over. The sniping between artists and their hangers-on are good, but the actual mystery feels very weak. Alleyn’s deduction is based on the knot the cartoon was tied with, but since we can’t see it, we can’t deduce from it. Not to mention I don’t know if we get a chance to see X make a knot before the reveal. Still, this entry shows why Bodies from the Library got six entries and two horror spinoffs. While I don’t care for Marsh and didn’t care for this script, I can’t deny that this is a genuine find, especially for fans of the author. Medawar has consistently done good work with this series, and he should be applauded for it. It would be crass to complain about it just because I didn’t like his selections.
The final six stories are all short ones. In 1938, the Sunday Dispatch commissioned “ two series of stories from the Crime Club, a publishing imprint created by the publishers William Collins.” These are from the first set, where the six writers were directed to write a story based on the prompt “One night a man picked up an orange in the street. This saved his life.”
Peter Cheyney (“The Orange Kid”) starts off rough with a gangster plotting the death of a subordinate…a killer with a perchance for bombs disguised as oranges! This is pretty whatever. Ethal Lina White (“And the answer was…”) has a clothing designer come into evidence that a beloved mayor is a Jeckell-and-Hyde style serial killer. The orange ex machina is a little silly but the telling is good. David Hume (“He Stooped to Live”) is similar to the Cheyney; gangster boss plots the destruction of another, this time with a murder frame-up. The orange clears him, as one would expect.
Nicholas Blake (“Mr. Prendergast and the Orange”) is up next with a Nigel Strangeways story, although he doesn’t do much beyond stepping to save the titular Prendergast from the charge of killing his aunt. The key evidence? You guessed it. Better constructed than the previous ones, with some actual foreshadowing. John Rhode (“The Yellow Sphere”) gives us one of those dissolute nephews that fill the annals of the Golden Age of Detection scheming to dispose of his uncle by sabotaging his houseboat. And it would have worked too, if not for the orange. Pretty good. But why a “yellow” sphere? Finally, William Collins himself (“The ‘Eat More Fruit’ Murder”) gives us the account of Mr. Hildegard Silvercat, who escapes a murder frame-up thanks to a fallen orange. Once again, not bad, this could have made a good long piece.
I find all of these stories to be Fine ™. The authors vary it up a little but it’s hard to escape the feeling of sameness.
Overall, Bodies from the Library 3 is really good. I wish that there were more classic whodunits on display, but I can’t deny that what we got is pretty good; the Sayers, Carr, Christie, and Commings alone would make this collection worth it. Worth a look for casual and hardcore mystery lovers alike. Recommended.
Other Reviews: Ah, Sweet Mystery, crossexaminingcrime, In Search of the Classic Mystery Novel, FictionFan's Book Reviews.






